Skip to content

Should a CPA help a delinquent taxpayer? a criminal? a drug dealer?

January 9, 2015

A CPA posed a question online about whether he should help a person who had not filed income tax returns for years but now wants to come clean and catch up. It was surprising to me that almost all the CPAs who responded said they would not help. Many had strong logical arguments for their position. I felt strongly the opposite opinion and suspect that my position is based on past personal experience. This post explains why I would help a delinquent taxpayer.

Years ago I moved into a rural area where the government already knows that the region’s major industries (agriculture, fishing and illegal drug and alcohol imports) under-report income. There is a history of decades of violent disputes (i.e. the oyster wars, prohibition agents and now the DEA war on drugs) between citizens and government taxing authorities. Coincidently, today’s newspaper carries a story about a new expanded effort to curb illegal drug imports coming through the Delaware Bay. I don’t know that government appreciates the extent of the under-reported income issue even today. A substantial number, perhaps the majority, of self-employed individuals around here do not file tax returns. Official state documents verify that they know this is true. Two I know (older American born neighbors) did not even have social security numbers. I’ve slowly been involved in bringing my neighbors into the modern world. This involved mundane issues like obtaining verification of identity, giving them access to the Internet, requiring that they get drivers licenses to borrow my truck, etc. It is arguable as to whether I’ve made life better or worse for them. In fact, sometimes I am accused of destroying the old nostalgic lifestyle of the region. But the clear end result is that I’ve increased revenues to government. In that, I take confidence. Sure, we they still have a long way to go until we reach what a CPA would call “compliance”. Yet I have no fear of professional retribution while I follow this path.

In my way of thinking, even small progress toward a desirable end goal is better than completely ignoring the issue.

I would hope to stick to these well-supported professional principles in my work:
1) If I believe that a business person honestly wants to “come clean” and come into tax compliance I have no ethical problem helping them.

2) Filing a tax return, even with errors, is always better than not filing at all.

3) Estimates are a perfectly reasonable basis of filing when other evidence is not available,

4) In most cases a creative and diligent CPA can find adequate support for the positions taken in a tax return,

5) Past behavior, even criminal behavior, should not bar a taxpayer from professional representation. Just as an ER doctor does not refuse to treat a gun shot patient in a drug deal gone bad, I would not refuse to represent a criminal solely on that basis. If we support the right to professional representation then this right is not tested by representing those you like, but by giving the same vigorous effort to those whose opinions and actions are not in line with our own.

In addition, I add these two personal beliefs that are not supported by any professional position:

1) I should consider taking on a client in this situation when I can afford to do so as a service to society even if it is unprofitable,

2) I won’t run my business based on fear of liability.

I would avoid getting into any discussion as to whether a client’s past behavior indicates future behavior. Not that this is not a valid point but rather simply that I do not think that I am qualified to discuss the topic intelligently.

The bottom line is that there should be room for professional difference of opinion on this sensitive issue in order to meet the wide range of real life situations that exist in the world.

From → accounting, taxes, values

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: